Conceiving the Inconceivable: A Scientific Commentary on the Vedānta Sūtra by Ashish Dalela

Enlightenment in the West was predicated on the idea that the questions of the soul and God cannot be answered through reason, and therefore, we must stop asking such questions. Vedānta arrived at a different conclusion 500 years ago in the Acintyabhedābheda philosophy of Sri Chaitanya: the questions of the soul and God cannot be answered through reason, and therefore, we must answer them through devotion. The rejection of the ultimate questions, or the rejection of their rational understanding, are both unsatisfactory, and this commentary on Vedānta Sutra arises out of that dissatisfaction.It traces the problem to the nature of language: words have multiple meanings, but they cannot be applied simultaneously. Each type of meaning is instead revealed in a different context. The problem of irrationality is the contradiction between language and logic: linguistic truth is contextual, and logical truth is universal. To solve this problem, we need a modal conception of reality in which everything exists as a combination of three modes (called by various names in Vedic philosophy), but one of these modes is dominant at one time, place, or circumstance, while the others are subordinated. Logic is the change in mode priorities, and contradictory claims can be true, although not simultaneously.Thus, God, matter, and soul, are three modes, called puruṣa, prakriti, and jīvā, and the world is created by their combination, but they cannot be known simultaneously. The soul is known when matter is subordinated, and God is known when the soul is subordinated. Knowledge is complete if three modes are used, consistent if they are not used simultaneously, and rational if logic is the process of mode change. This view of reality reconciles all previous Vedānta positions as different modes of description; hence Advaita, Viśiṣṭādvaita, Dvaita, and Bhedābheda are true, but not simultaneously. Simultaneity leads to achintya or inconceivability, but non-simultaneity leads to chintya or conceivability.

Also Review

Is the Apple Really Red?: 10 Essays on Science and Religion by Ashish Dalela

The Yellow Pill: Conceptual Basis of the Varna System by Ashish Dalela

Uncommon Wisdom: Fault Lines in the Foundations of Atheism by Ashish Dalela

Western Questions Eastern Answers: A Collection of Short Essays (Volume 1) by Ashish Dalela

Quantum Meaning: A Semantic Interpretation of Quantum Theory by Ashish Dalela

Six Causes: The Vedic Theory of Creation by Ashish Dalela

Cosmic Theogony: The Personalization of Nature by Ashish Dalela

Mystic Universe: An Introduction to Vedic Cosmology by Ashish Dalela

Vedic Cosmology and Ethics Selected Studies by Henk W Bodewitz

Vedic Cosmology by Danavir Goswami

Occult Cosmology by Bruce Lyon and Chic Cicero

Cosmology Course I by Willi Sucher

The Vedic Big Bang (2 Vol Set): A New Cosmology Scenario Revealed in The Ancient Veda Mantras of India by Shiv R Pal

Mantra: Sacred Words of Power by Thomas Ashley Farrand

Mantra Anushthan Prakash मन्त्रानुष्ठान प्रकाश (Hindi) by Jawahar Lal karmahe

Mantra Shakti मन्त्र शक्ति (Hindi) by Rudradev Tripathi

Mantra: The Primordial Energy by S Krishnamurthy

Yoga of the Planets (All 9 Grahas): Their Mantras and Philosophy by Andrew Foss

Living Mantra: Mantra, Deity and Visionary Experience Today by Mani Rao

Infallible Vedic Remedies: Mantras for Common Problems by Swami Shantananda Puri

Mangal Mantra Namokar: Ek Anuchintan मंगल मंत्र णमोकार: एक अनुचिंतन (Hindi) by Nemi Chandra Shastri

Practicals of Mantra and Tantra by L R Chawdhri

Jaina Method of Curing with Bhaktamer Strotra (48 Miraculous Tools of Bhaktamar Stotra with Yantra, Mantra & Riddhi Book) by Manju Jain

Mantrams: Their Significance and Practice by Sri K Parvathi Kumar

Secrets of Yantra, Mantra and Tantra by L R Chawdhri

Mantra Sagar (मन्त्र सागर) by Rameshwar Prasad Tripathi (Hindi) 1990

Hanuman Tantra Sadhna हनुमान तंत्र साधना (Hindi) by Radhakrishna Shrimali

Hanuman Siddhi हनुमान सिद्धि (Hindi) by Adyanand Yashpal Bharti

Gayathri Rahasyam गायत्री रहस्यम (Hindi) by Shiv Dutta Mishra

Durga Tantram दुर्गातन्त्रम (Hindi) by Shiv Dutta Mishra

Hanumad Rahasyam हनुमद्-रहस्यम्: Complete Method of Worshipping Lord Hanuman (Hindi) by Shiv Dutta Mishra

Sri Chakra by S Shankarnarayan

The Asvamedha: The Rite and its Logic by Subhash Kak

Tantra Sadhana Saar तंत्र साधना सार (Hindi) by Dev Dutta Shastri

Tantra Sidhant Aur Sadhana तंत्र सिद्धान्त और साधना (Hindi) by Dev Dutta Shastri

Bhuta Damara Tantra भूत डामर तन्त्र (Hindi) by Krishna Kumar Rai

Kundalini Shakti: Yog Tantrik Sadhana Prasang कुण्डलिनी शक्ति: योग तांत्रिक साधना प्रसंग (Hindi) by Arun Kumar Sharma

Mantra Shakti मन्त्र शक्ति (Hindi) by Rudradev Tripathi

Yantra Shakti यन्त्र शक्ति (Hindi) – Part II by Rudradev Tripathi

Yantra Shakti यन्त्र शक्ति (Hindi) – Part I by Rudradev Tripathi

Bhuta Damara Tantra भूत डामर तन्त्र (Hindi) by Krishna Kumar Rai

Ecstasy Through Tantra (Llewellyns Tantra and Sexual Arts Series) by Jonn Mumford

The Tantra of Śrī Chakra by S K Ramachandra Rao

Panchadashi Tantra पञ्चदशीतन्त्र (Hindi) (Published by Khemraj)

Ravan’s Kumar Tantra कुमारतन्त्र (Health) (Hindi) by Ravi Dutt

Brihat Tantra Sara बृहत्तन्त्रसार Part II (Hindi) by Kapildev Narayan

Brihat Tantra Sara बृहत्तन्त्रसार Part I (Hindi) by Kapildev Narayan

Jain Tantra Sashtra जैन तन्त्र-शास्त्र (Hindi) by Rajesh Dixit and Yatindra Kumar Jain Shastri

Laghu Vidyanuvad  (Jain Tantra, Mantra, Yantra Vidya) लघु विद्यानवाद  यंत्र, मंत्र, तंत्र विद्या (Hindi) by Gandhar Aacharya Kunthu Sagar Maharaj

The Art of Tantra by Philip Rawson

Practicals of Mantra and Tantra by L R Chawdhri

Practicals of Yantra by L R Chawdhri

The Yantras: Text with 32 Plates by S K Ramachandra Rao

Tantra Mantra Yantra: The Tantra Psychology by S K Ramachandra Rao

Brihat Upaye Samhita (Hindi) by Arun K Bansal

Astro Remedies – A Vedic Approach by Raj Kumar

Nadi Astrology – Accurate Predictive Methodology by Umang Taneja

Prashna (Nadi Stellar Astrology) – A Contemporary Treatise by Umang Taneja

Advertisement